Best Pizza in Grand Rapids
Treat your taste buds to the best that Grand Rapids has to offer in this Wander West best Pizza list. From pop-ups turned permanent pizza shops to old-fashioned classics that have stood the test of time – this article has it all.
If you are looking for the best pizza, Wander West knows the BEST options for you – yelp and customer reviews, as well as personal experience, have shown us the Way – the “Pizza Path,” if you will – and we are inviting you along the journey!
So, read along and save this post for later when you’re craving the “pizza in that online article you read earlier.”… 🙂
Disclaimer: Affiliate links are used, which means if you purchase via my link, I receive a small commission at no additional cost to you! I only recommend products I use and love!
Pin for Later!
1. QUARANTINO’S
1444 Lake Dr., Grand Rapids
Quarantino’s is unique in that yes – it’s name is inspired by its origin, since this delicious pizza joint began as a pop-up in response to quarantining during the pandemic starting in 2020. Four years later, it has become a permanent staple in the West Michigan Pizza community and certainly not something you want to miss out on! Their menu features specials such as: Quarantino Special, VEGAN cheesy breadsticks (a delicious vegan menu, INCLUDING Chocolate Truffles!), and even a secret menu you can find by visiting their website. So grab your vegan and meat-eating friends alike, and check out this delightfully inclusive pizza joint.
Pera Pizzeria
56 Monroe Center St NW, Grand Rapids
Located right in the heart of downtown, Pera Pizzeria has brought a slice of Italy to Grand Rapids with fresh ingredients and a menu designed for pizza lovers. Known for its hand-stretched dough, this spot offers a variety of toppings like arugula, prosciutto, and house-made mozzarella, making each pizza truly memorable. Their wood-fired oven adds that authentic Italian touch and regulars rave about the “Bella Italia” pizza—a delightful blend of truffle oil, mushrooms, and fontina cheese. Pera’s cozy, welcoming atmosphere makes it perfect for date nights or gatherings with friends!
3. Martha’s Pizza
5080 Cascade Rd SE, Grand Rapids
A hidden gem among locals, Martha’s Pizza is known not only for its delicious offerings but also for its friendly, down-to-earth vibe. Martha’s takes pride in using farm-fresh ingredients and crafts each pizza with love. Their “Grand River Special” standout pie combines smoked sausage, sweet peppers, and caramelized onions on a perfectly crisp crust. Be sure to check out their unique seasonal specials, which highlight Michigan’s local produce. Martha’s is as much a part of the community as it is a place to grab an amazing slice!
4. Grecos Pizza
1601 Leonard St NW, Grand Rapids
An old-school favorite, Grecos Pizza has been a go-to for pizza in Grand Rapids since the 80s. Known for its thick, pillowy crust and signature sauce, Grecos serves up classic pies that are generously topped and full of flavor. Their “Leonard Street Deluxe” is a fan favorite, featuring pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and green peppers in every cheesy bite. Grecos’ casual, laid-back setting and large portion sizes make it perfect for families and anyone craving an authentic pizza experience.
5. Cottage Inn Pizza
2830 E Beltline Ave NE, Grand Rapids
Cottage Inn has earned its place as a neighborhood staple, offering a vast menu for everyone, including gluten-free and vegetarian options. Their specialty pies, like the “BBQ Chicken Pizza,” are loaded with unique toppings that pack a punch. Cottage Inn is known for its family-friendly atmosphere and late hours, making it the ideal spot for both casual dinners and late-night cravings.
6. Pizzami
932 Lake Dr SE, Grand Rapids
With its warm, inviting interior, Pizzami is a family-run pizzeria specializing in bold flavors and quality ingredients. Their signature “White Wonder” pizza, with garlic cream sauce, roasted garlic, and mozzarella, is a must-try for garlic lovers. Beyond pizza, they offer calzones, pasta, and fresh salads, making it a well-rounded spot for Italian food lovers. Pizzami’s welcoming vibe and generous portions have made it a favorite for locals and visitors alike.
7. The Foolery
1017 Wealthy St SE, Grand Rapids
The Foolery is a dive bar down the road that everyone knows! They specialize in delicious Detroit-style pizza and tom-foolery, as the name suggests. They boast “really good square pizza,” but it’s so much more than that! With cocktails, beer, and mood lighting to match the spirits – there’s something for everyone at this delectable West Michigan pizza destination.
8. Palermo Pizza & Restaurant
2903 Breton Rd SE, Grand Rapids
Palermo Pizza has brought the traditional flavors of Italy to Grand Rapids, offering authentic Sicilian-style pizzas and pasta dishes that are made from scratch. Their garlic knots and “Palermo Special”—topped with Italian sausage, roasted peppers, and olives—are crowd-pleasers. Whether dining in or taking out, you can count on Palermo for a delicious, home-style Italian meal that leaves a lasting impression.
9. Buddy’s Pizza
4061 28th St SE, Grand Rapids
A Detroit legend with a strong reputation, Buddy’s Pizza is the place to go for classic Detroit-style square pizza. Known for its thick crust, crispy edges, and generous toppings, Buddy’s offers local favorites like the “Detroiter,” topped with double cheese, pepperoni, and caramelized onions. It’s a must-visit for anyone wanting to experience authentic Detroit-style pizza without leaving Grand Rapids.
10. Fricano’s Pizza Tavern
5808 Alpine Ave NW, Grand Rapids
Fricano’s has been serving up pizza since 1949, and their thin-crust pies are beloved by many for their classic simplicity. This no-frills joint keeps it old-school with traditional toppings like pepperoni and mushrooms on a perfectly crisp crust. For a real taste of Michigan’s pizza history, try the “Classic Fricano,” which many say is the best thin-crust pizza in the state.
11. Pietro’s Italian Restaurant
2750 Birchcrest Dr SE, Grand Rapids
Pietro’s serves up the best authentic Italian fare, including an entire menu page of different kinds of pasta, and their pizzas are no exception either! Known for using imported ingredients and traditional techniques, they offer a rich array of flavors on every slice. Their “Siciliano Supreme” pizza is a popular choice, topped with an indulgent mix of Italian meats, basil, and fresh mozzarella. Perfect for anyone who appreciates the finer points of Italian cuisine! Be sure to check them out when you’re craving a slice.
12. Licari’s Sicilian Pizza Kitchen
2869 Knapp St NE, Grand Rapids
If you’re in the mood for Sicilian-style pizza, Licari’s is a must-visit. Their “Sophia” pizza, topped with prosciutto, figs, and truffle oil, is both unique and unforgettable. This cozy spot blends authentic Sicilian ingredients with a modern twist, giving their pizzas a distinct gourmet edge. Licari’s has become a hit among foodies and casual diners alike for its inventive flavors and welcoming atmosphere.
13. Mitten Brewing Co.
527 Leonard St NW, Grand Rapids
While Mitten Brewing Co. might be better known for its craft beers, their pizzas are not to be overlooked. Their “Westerdog” pizza—a unique twist featuring hot dogs, mustard, and pickles—is a favorite for those looking to try something different. Set in a vintage baseball-themed space, Mitten Brewing Co. offers a fun, nostalgic atmosphere along with some truly delicious pizzas that pair perfectly with their house brews.
—
From artisan wood-fired pies to classic thick-crust delights, Grand Rapids has a pizza spot for every kind of pizza lover. No matter what style you’re craving, this list has the perfect slice waiting for you! Enjoy the “Pizza Path” as you explore the best pies the city has to offer.
Make a weekend of it!
Find other fun places to eat in Grand Rapids- HERE!
Logan Imber
Logan Imber is a self taught Freelance Digital Marketer & Copywriter currently located in Ohio, but works remotely for clients all over the world. She also dabbles in Graphic Design, Web Design and Music. She doesn't like to pin herself down, as there is always something to learn, a culture to take in or new food to eat. In her free time, Logan likes reading, yoga, and spending time with her beloved cat. She also loves playing and sharing music with others. Essentially, most of her time is either spent writing, contemplating, or creating something - and she wouldn't have it any other way.
- Logan Imber#molongui-disabled-link
- Logan Imber#molongui-disabled-link
- Logan Imber#molongui-disabled-link
- Logan Imber#molongui-disabled-link
